best amish restaurants in ohio
There are so many wonderful places to get comfort food in Ohio. Someone mentioned these two names of restaurants in Lancaster County. It serves the non-Amish customers of the market, but Im pretty sure its Amish-owned since everything else in the market is. They are my favorite. A very worthwhile, memorable experience. My name is Justin Quinn and and I hope that you will welcome this idea and not take offense. The Amish tour train no longer operates. Best selection & most expensive), Millers Smorgasboard in Yonks, PA What was once a grocery store in the 1930s is now a beloved Amish restaurant that locals and visitors can't get enough of. We make the most of our moments at mealtime; its a tradition we treasure. have to be Yoders down it pinecraft, the little retirement settlement in Sarasota Florida. We also love going to the Kidron Town and Country Store and Restaurant. The market offers your favorite meats and cheeses, bulk foods/candies/spices, jellies, relishes, and gifts. While youre there, make your own peanut butter or take home a gift basket full of their famous goodies! Wish we had some Amish restaurants in New York State near where I live. Berlin Farmstead, 4757 Township Rd 366, Berlin, OH 44610, USA, 1343 Old Rte 39 NE, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, USA, For some of the best Amish cuisine in southeast Ohio, check out this beloved, Olde Dutch, 12791 OH-664, Logan, OH 43138, USA, What was once a grocery store in the 1930s is now a beloved, Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant, 4819 E Main St, Berlin, OH 44610, USA. Not good for the waistline or the wallet (its not expensive but we go too often!) The large market includes a sliced-to-order deli, special recipe meat shop, Amish and Mennonite local grown fruits and vegetables, made-from-scratch bakery, and on site cannery with jams, jellies, sauces and more. If youre visiting Amish Country as a tourist, but want to eat where the locals eat, be sure to stop by Rebeccas Bistro. Dutch Valley Kitchen, Sugar creek Ohio Some of the most popular dishes include scrapple, shoofly pie, and Dutch cabbage rolls. The owners of the Amish Door first poured coffee and served broasted chicken for dinner in March 1977. Peachey & Sons - The best We are surrounded by Amish here in PA and this is our absolute favorite place to visit. There were long tables pushed together, and we chatted with strangers as we waited. Dutch Valley Restaurant, Park Street Pizza, Bags Sports Pub, The Pizza Parlor, and more. Rebecca's Bistro (Sugarcreek) Rebecca's Bistro/Facebook Have you been to any of these stores or markets before? 330 248 7034 Hmm. Set in an oversized Amish style home that has a seating capacity of 450, Enjoy an exceptionally delicious family-style Amish meal in this 1850s farmhouse. Walnut Creek, OH William I am assuming that no one has opened a PA Dutch style place in your neck of the woods yet? Oh, the chocolate fondue. Check out my post on the Best wineries in Amish Country over at amishcountrytraveler.com. Aaron Peachey Have heard excellent things about Dienners and will try that on our next trip to PA in Sept. /12. Im not sure its anything special, but the food is filling and simple, and the restaurants easy to find, once you know its name. The buffalo cauliflower is an appetizer youll drool over, and the Bucking Cheeseburger is so good! To learn more, visit their website, Set in an oversized Amish style home that has a seating capacity of 450, this restaurant is located in Wilmont. This trendy establishment appeals to tourists and locals for its mix of everything from hearty roast beef and mashed potatoes to shrimp and grits. Now a museum, its a full-size replica of a European castle and features a hodge-podge of different architectural styles from a slew of European countries. It is located at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Amish cuisine is rich and hearty. Ohio's oldest general store appropriately sits in the heart of Amish Country. Love the broasted chicken, salad bar and everything else at The Amish Door in Wilmot. And old world bakerys macaroons are seriously fantastic! 30 just east of Lancaster. Id love to take my children there one day. However, the German-style cooking hung on in the family line, and my fathers mother was German, so that style was familiar to him, too. It has a real small hometown feel to it, although they are a very busy restaurant. What are people saying about amish restaurant in Holmes County, OH? We tend to hit Heini's for some cheese samples and then run over to Kauffman bakery across the street for some samples there at least once a month. Canal Tavern of Zoar Great food! So if you want a place where Amish frequent often, Id stick with Mrs. Yoders . What are the best Amish restaurants in Ohio? Cash or check only. Charlene Edwards/Unsplash. Amish Country Donuts Donut Shops Coffee Shops Restaurants (15) Website (330) 852-5214 522 Dover Rd NE Sugarcreek, OH 44681 2. Looking for more help planning your trip to Amish County? Please contact me on email or at 513 208 8385. Peachey & Sons, Inc. Aaron Peachey 72 Barrville Rd. Amish homemade style food such as roasted chicken, roast beef, ham, mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, corn, green beans, noodles, salad bar, Amish casserole and much more. The following are 10 of our favorite Ohio Amish Country stores and markets where youll find some incredible homemade goods and other treats. The restaurant is open Monday-Saturday from 7 am- 8 pm. I do not know of a resturant by either of those names, I do know of a Reihls craft place on an amish farm. Laurareally a great story. served, except there was a lot of everything! Best amish restaurant near me in Mansfield, Ohio Sort:Recommended Price Offers Delivery Offers Takeout Good for Kids Good for Dinner Accepts Credit Cards 1. I was pleasantly surprised by Bags when I was home for a visit. After a hearty dinner, remember to stop by the The Amish Door Bakery. It?s so different than other options. (The salad options here are also very popular. Middlebury and Wana Cup in Shipshewana. dasdutchvillage.com Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant Their goal is to provide the freshest, tastiest product at a reasonable price with quality, friendly service.. An attached bakery allows visitors to take home the restaurants baked goods and an assortment of pies. Be sure to pick up a few of their delicious cinnamon rolls for later! Sure, well pass the potatoes. Why choose fast food with all that good Swiss fare around? All throughout the region, youll find several charming stores and one-of-a-kind markets that make it hard to choose where to stop. Ive never been to an Amish eatery, just a market stall with a few stools. Cheap and basic food, homemade. (Its at the corner of US 20 and State Road 5.). We keep it casual. Love Ohio? Scripps School of Journalism. 330 893 2981 A rustic restaurant serving delicious homestyle meals plus a buffet, Berlin Farmstead is located in the heart of Ohio's Amish Country and is by far one of the most popular restaurants there. we highly suggest that you try it and you will I was really disappointed. Learn how your comment data is processed. a beautiful setting next to a lake. To learn more, visit their website, This award-winning southeast Ohio barbecue joint features a diverse menu, from Louisiana Crab Cakes to slow cooked ribs and pulled pork. To learn more, visit their website here. b) They somehow manage to remember its exact position, My favorite is Rebeccas! The favorites of my wife and I are Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury Indiana and Der Dutchman Essenhaus in Walnut Creek Ohio. Family-owned Coblentz Chocolate has beautiful hand-dipped gourmet truffles, candies, treats, and gifts handcrafted from the heart. When visiting the store be sure to stop by their viewing gallery to watch some of their amazing confections being made. It is located at 8101 State Route 241, Mt. Excellent list Marie and nice to see a Canadian entry. Hershberger's Farm and Bakery 543 reviews Closed today Dessert, American $ "Great Place to shop and go for a Buggy." "Great place to visit!" 3. But always good service. Guests of all ages can eat, shop and relax at the complex. They wouldnt be as likely to eat out in a restaurant as the Old Order are. Closest thing we have to an Amish restaurant down this way. (330)359-5464 What are the best places to get comfort food in Ohio? Find It Here; 15 Amish Restaurants - Ohio; 16 The Amish Door; 17 Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen: Amish Food in Ohio's Amish Country; 18 4 Surprising Food Finds . The baseball season seems too long by about 100 games. A wide variety of traditional favorites are offered as well as an affordable breakfast buffet, All You Can Eat Salad Bar, and their famous Lunch and Dinner Grand Buffet. Restaurant & Bakery Hours: Monday-Saturday. The Amish Door Restaurant Were so lucky to live in a state thats full of rolling hillsides and gorgeous views. Thank you! info@whiteoakinn.com. Does anyone know what happened to Shriners Flowers across from the Gordonville Book Store? Specializing in Amish style meals, sandwiches, salad, desserts, and daily specials. Amish Door is just a few minutes away we stopped going there as often as we did when they raised the prices much higher and the food seemed not as tasty as in previous years, but the last few times weve gone its been more like the old days (and busier again, which is good). The roast beef is like no other roast beef Ive ever tasted, and the dressing is made with a cornbread base. For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Though youll have Amish employees, particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish just havent taken a lot of ownership in the restaurant industry. Theyre also known for making exceptional apple butter. This Stunning Lodge Offers An Affordable, Resort-Level Getaway In One Of Ohios Most Beautiful State Parks, Youll Swear Youre Dining In A European Bistro When You Visit This Cafe In Small Town Ohio, The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, 12 Hidden Gems Along The Ohio Countryside That Are So Worth The Drive, The Awesome Store Every Ohioan Should Tour At Least Once, Why People Go Crazy For This One Pie In Small Town Ohio, The Gigantic Fruit Spread Store In Ohio Youll Want To Visit Over And Over Again, unique hardware store in the middle of nowhere, Tis The Season Christmas Shoppe in Millersburg, this road trip to the best Amish country stores. Plan ahead for a Winter Cheese making tour. From seafood to pasta, this place has it all. You'll find it at 4986 Walnut St, Sugarcreek, OH 44681. How can I learn about more Amish stores near me in Ohio? If the restaurants are anything like Indiana?s Amish area, it is totally worth a visit! Fill your belly. You will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. The Barn Inn is located at 6838 County Road 203 Millersburg, OH, 44654. And I also want to suggest the Salt Creek Cafe in Fredericksburg, it is fantastic, great food, really good prices too. Many of us wonder where, exactly Amish Country in Ohio is; youll find stretched across multiple counties and small rural towns in the central part of the state! So embarassing! Looking for a place to stay? End of the Commons General Store has been in operation since the 1840s and is located at 4366 Kinsman Rd., Mesopotamia, OH, 44439. Good food and Kidron OH Rebecca's Bistro is located at 4986 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH. Its where all the buggies are, of course! Located in Berlin, Ohio, Boyd & Wurthmann use employ real Amish cooks to ensure authentic Amish cuisine. 5201 CR 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 Heinis Cheese Chalet What others would you add to this list? It is located at 4653 N State Route 60 NW, McConnelsville, OH 43756. The Amish wedding steak also comes highly-recommended! Website. Its always packed, with a lot of localsnever a bad sign. East Main Kitchen offers a kids menu and plenty of seating for families. When I was in Pennsylvania my friends said they were taking me to an Amish restaurant. Growing up my folks would take us to Shippshewane (sp?!) Thank you! Best VIEW while dining-Der Dutchman, Walnut Creek OH The bucolic beauty of Ohios Amish Country truly is unrivaled. In addition to their huge selection of bulk items, they also offer deli meats, cheese, and locally grown Amish produce, jams, jellies, pasta and much more. Columbiana, OH You cant leave a brewery without trying a beer, right? Its so popular now there can be lines waiting to get in but well worth the wait. One of the, Shisler's Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH 44667, USA. Das Essehaus, Middlebury Indiana In Lancaster County, I love Shady Maple Smorgasboard (wear your pants with the elactic), Yoders, Dienners, Family Cupboard, Oregon Dairy. We are so happy that we found another restaurant owned/run by Amish people. Nothing hits the spot quite like down-home cooking paired with heartwarming. She looked at that can for a moment, then said, Why not? After that, pork and noodles was a semi-regular thing at our house, too. 14A, Penn Yan, NY. Guests can also choose to have a full family sized Amish style meal prepared instead of individual orders. We put together this road trip to the best Amish country stores in Ohio, and youll be delighted to find that there are stores located pretty much a stones through from whatever corner of the Buckeye State in which youre located! sang a few songs after dinner and the children recited a couple This Stunning Lodge Offers An Affordable, Resort-Level Getaway In One Of Ohios Most Beautiful State Parks, Youll Swear Youre Dining In A European Bistro When You Visit This Cafe In Small Town Ohio, The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, An All-You-Can-Eat Amish Buffet In Ohio, Dutch Kitchen Serves Some Of The Best Fried Chicken Around, 10 Rural Restaurants In Ohio That Serve Mouthwatering Homemade Meals, 9 Hometown Restaurants In Ohio That Will Take You Back In Time, In The Heart Of Amish Country, Rebeccas Bistro Might Be The Most Charming Restaurant In Ohio, Der Dutchman Restaurant and Bakery in Plain City/Facebook, broasted chicken from this down-home country buffet, Guggisberg's Chalet in the Valley/Facebook, Dutch Valley Restaurant and Bakery/Facebook, 11 Hometown Restaurants In Ohio That Will Take You Back In Time. 4967 Walnut Street, Walnut Creek, OH 44687 Today the restaurant specializes in Amish style cooking and homemade pies (15-20 different pies to choose from). Owned by the Mullet family, who are Mennonite. Valerie, My curiosity would lead me to focus in on every detail of the buggy, horses, tack; then at the last moment I would quickly turn my head so that they wouldnt see me staring. Mrs. Yoders has been providing home-style cooking to the local community for over 15 years. In business for decades, the store has grown into a local favorite and for good reason! 5 things to do in Amish Country, Ohio with kids, 5 Favorite Spots within Cuyahoga Valley National Park, The best Christmas lights in Mansfield, Ohio (2022), 5 Things to do in Amish Country, Ohio with kids -, Free things to do in Amish Country, Ohio with kids - yodertoterblog. Karla, you asked about Reihls and Zooks in Lancaster County. Pork? 6005 County Road 77, Millersburg, OH 44654 The address of Dutch Kitchen is 14278 Lincoln Way E., Dalton, OH 44618. 4959 Kidron Rd, Apple Creek, OH 44606. Below you will find a comprehensive guide to the best Amish restaurants in Ohio, but if you are hungry for more, simply download our free Amish Country Vacation Guide! Anything thats covered in Guggisbergs award-winning Swiss cheese. Best Amish Restaurant near me in Holmes County, Ohio Sort:Recommended Offers Delivery Offers Takeout 1. Its not a restaurant, but a large food store with all kinds of Dutch foods, bulk foods, cards, books, and wooden crafts and outside buildings. In the morning, you can greet the day with. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. If youre a lifelong Ohioan, then you know that some of the states best restaurants are hiding in rural Ohio. For more information, This unique store in Ohio Amish Country specializes in antique style appliances, retro home furnishings, non-electric kitchenware, old-time toys, and many more items that will take you back to yesteryear. 22611 Ohio 2 They are open from 5:30 am- 7:30 pm Monday Saturday. Very good, fresh food and very enjoyable people to be amongst for a meal. When she's not on deadline or chasing after her toddler, she's hunting for hidden gems in Ohio or getting lost in a good book. In addition to Amish Countrys best country fried steak, you will enjoy countless seasonal sweets and delicacies. Its a fun, old-fashioned place to eat. Read more about this, Spend your days exploring Ohio's Amish Country and your nights at this truly charming getaway, where relaxation and upscale casual dining abound. For more information, Walnut Creek Cheese, 2641 OH-39, Walnut Creek, OH 44687, USA, For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. The Amish Door Restaurant 1210 Winesburg St. Wilmot, OH 888 264 7436 amishdoor.com Restaurant located at the Amish Door Village in Wilmot, OH. 4 - 7pm $19.99. After a day of exploring Ohios Amish area, head home to our inn for a relaxing night in. We used to always go to Mrs Yoder?s Kitchen. Jump to: Holmes County Geauga County/Northeast OH Columbus Area Northwest OH. Ashery Country Store 8822 SR 241, Fredricksburg, OH 44627 (330)359-5615 Website Amish Door Restaurant With more than 10 years of writing experience and a background in news reporting for Ohio newspapers, she's published pieces in multiple print and online publications. The bakery is a must visit for your sweet tooth and carries a large selection of delicious cakes, cupcakes, donuts, pies, fritters, breads and more. It is confusing, and it took me awhile to distinguish that there is a difference between the Swiss and Amish type of business in the area. Even if lunch is light, theres time to lean back with coworkers while chatting over trail bologna and swiss sandwiches. Ashery Country Store Were working folk, so the champagne here is beer. Would sure like to get it. Oh, and the food is classic delicious Amish restaurant I particularly adore the meatloaf. Hope. This local watering hole serves some of the best hamburgers in the state. I believe its Mennonite owned. Their homemade Black Raspberry Cream Pie is a crowd favorite. Mennonite style home made dishes. Scripps School of Journalism. Mrs Yoders Kitchen, 8101 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA 3. (330)893-3786 Here youll find one of the states most heartwarming regions thats truly one of the most charming places to explore in the Midwest. (330)852-4257 Marie B, Windsor Ontario Canada. All Rights Reserved. Formerly Grandmas Homestead Restaurant. A piece of rhubarb crumb pie or a buttery coconut cupcake is the perfect way to end your meal. Who has recipe for Annapolis Amish market meatloaf? Do try Beachys Country Chalet Restaurant in Sugarcreek OH. Oh, Tiffanys in Topeka, Ind. I am so sorry to have led you astray about it. Mrs. Yoders Kitchen Call ahead before visiting: 330-893-2550.*. Cindys Diner But yes, I didnt add it to the list because I havent been there since high school. Charm, OH I only know of a Zooks store and the Reihls craft barn too. Handicap accessible. I havent checked winter. Castles and Ohio might seem like an odd pairing, but one visit to this castle and youll quickly forget your reservations. Believe it or not, Boyd and Wurthmann will still serve you a cup of coffee for 99 cents! made from local farm-fresh eggs, and produce and herbs from our own garden. I wish I had the experience of eating at an Amish restaurant, I imagine it would be homey. As an added bonus, you can get some amazing smoked sausage, beef jerky, Trail Bologna, and more. 888 264 7436 It's one of our. When it comes to great shopping, Amish stores in Ohio cant be beat! For even more fantastic fare, visit The Olde Dutch Restaurant in Logan. Peachey & Sons The best We are surrounded by Amish here in PA and this is our absolute favorite place to visit. Im all about those cheese samples at Heinis. 6050 OH-515, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA 10. Free shipping for many products! The Little-Known Park In Ohio That Transforms Into An Ice Palace In The Winter, The Scenic North Coast Route That Leads To 5 Ohio Lighthouses, Theres Nothing More Enchanting Than A Winter Getaway To This Ohio Small Town, With An Abandoned Blast Furnace And 2,983 Acres To Explore, This Underrated Ohio State Park Is A Must-Visit, The Largest Quilt Barn In Ohio Is Truly A Sight To See, The Unique Tour That Will Take You Deep Into Ohio Amish Country Like Never Before, This Charming Little Farm Town In Ohio Is The Perfect Place To Get Away From It All, 9 Ohio Amish Country Restaurants With Food So Good Youll Be Back For Seconds. (Menus are available from their website.). Google also confirms that it is Permanently Closed. What I do remember was the shoofly pie! of poems. We also frequent Hometown restaurant on Furnace Road when in the area. Peachey & Sons, Inc. In Ohio Amish Country, we gather at the table to share food and friendship. Attlee grows his own green beans, potatoes, onions, garlic, zucchini, and tomatoes and sells local berries, corn, peaches . What are the best remote restaurants in Ohio? Very good. Some of the most popular menu items include the slow roast turkey and homemade stuffing. Pies are outstanding! On a previous post I was lightly chastised for eating at Subway while in the Berne Amish settlement. Hope (How does a man know which hat to leave with when he hangs them on the hat rack, they all look the same?) Website. Both. That is why I asked. ! Thank you! These are both on the National Road and the Casselman Bridge is right by the Penn Alps. * Indigestion (As an added bonus, the formerly Amish inn-keepers can give you firsthand insight into the culture and Amish faith.) The food is good but I would say leans toward the Swiss/German type of food. End of the Commons General Store is Ohios oldest general store, and it can be found, appropriately, in the heart of Amish Country. Amish Home Cooked Meals Bulk Foods & Bakeries Family & Amish Restaurants Foodie Fare Produce & Specialty Foods Cheese & Bites Wineries & Breweries Fresh Food from the Homestead Places to Stay Places to Stay Bed & Breakfasts, Inns Cabins & Cottages Hotels RV Parks & Campgrounds 3-Day Romantic Wine Tour Culture Culture Check out these hotels in Walnut Creek, Ohio. Hope, OH, 44660. (800)338-9341 Dare I dream to see the blue birds v Nats? 419 445 2231 Weve been having dinner there for approximately 26 years, and the food hasnt changed. It is well worth the trip to experience Sauders. We try to go every couple months as its about an hour from our home. To learn more, visit their website, Enjoy authentic Swiss, Austrian and American cuisine in the heart of Holmes County at Guggisberg's Chalet in the Valley. That is less common. Id definitely want to head over to Walnut Creek and try Der Dutchman. While there, but sure to allow time to observe the cheese making process through their factory viewing windows, Monday-Friday from 8am to 12pm. In addition to their huge selection of bulk items, they also offer deli meats, cheese, and locally grown Amish produce, jams, jellies, pasta and much more. Restaurant features breakfast, lunch, dinner menu and dessert. I have searched all over & cant seem to find any. Required fields are marked *. There are so many spectacular Amish restaurants in Ohio. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. Love Ohio? For more information, click, "The Little Switzerland of Ohio" covers a total area of a little more than three and a half square miles. a) They write their names on the inside of the hat (not much use if theyre all called Miller), Looking for Amish Country Wineries? Theres something special about a midsummer Saturday spent sipping ros on a breezy deck while live music plays. And in the Daviess County, Indiana area I like Stolls Lakeview To learn more, visit their website, For some of the best old-fashioned cooking in Ohio, be sure to check out this Amish Country gem. Is Rebeccas Bistro worth the wait? To learn more, visit their website, Located in the village of Walnut Creek, coming here almost feels like you're visiting a friendly neighbor for the afternoon, rather than eating at a restaurant. The Blue Gate Restaurant and Bakery. Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant is located at 4819 East Main St., Berlin, OH 44610. It may runneth over with our distinctive brew selections. This little restaurant will whisk you back to a simpler time. Jewels, thanks for the update on the status of Millers Dutch Kitchn. 5060 State Route 557, Millersburg, OH 44654, Open May through November, Sweetwater Farm offers its, own farmers market with a full line of fresh fruits and vegetables. My favorite though is still Mrs. Yoders in Mt. 340, and the Dutch-Way Restaurant/Markets in Gap and Myerstown. Amazing Amish restaurants in Ohio are plentiful; however, one that shouldnt be missed is Boyd and Wurthmann Restaurant in Berlin. If you are searching for homemade cooking, Ohios Amish area is the perfect place to start. Marilyn, Essenhaus is located at 1300 NY Rt. Re: Best Amish Restaurant in and around town. ),youll also find lots of opportunities to stop and enjoy a bit of the local culture. The restaurant offers German & Swiss delights like fondue and wiener schnitzel, but they also have a variety of American dishes. Thanks for your good work! And, its off the beaten path where we enjoy our Amish journey the best any other new Amish restaurants besides Katies in that area due to elderly parents illness we have been unable to travel to Lancaster area in last 10 or so months. 330 482 2236 There are exceptions though. Cant go wrong with anything on the menu ! Dutch Kitchen. Mrs. Yoder's Kitchen features a hearty buffet, delicious homemade pies and an at-home atmosphere we know you'll love. Of course, the name doesnt always tell you everything. Get even more stories delivered right to your email. saudervillage.org I was in Baltic just a few weeks ago and it appears Millers Dutch Kitchn is closed. The food was VERY reasonable and tasty. You will receive your first email soon. Colliers Family Restaurant, located in Springfield, is one of the best places to get comfort food in Ohio. Let us know! Brews in Ohio Amish Country? Also I would say that Chalet In The Valley is more Swiss/German than Amish. Amish Door is located at 1210 Winesburg St., Wilmot, OH 44689. For more information, 4147 Co Rd 114, Sugarcreek, OH 44681, USA, This gorgeous 116-acre Amish home and farm is open seasonally. With one-of-a-kind, hand-crafted items, special events and an unforgettable setting, Homestead Furniture, 8233 OH-241, Mt Hope, OH 44660, USA, This lovely Millersburg farm and bakery is the perfect day trip destination or stop when you're exploring, Hershberger's Farm and Bakery, 5452 OH-557, Millersburg, OH 44654, USA, This family-owned country store is hiding some of the most delicious cheese in the state. Salads are always fresh and cold. Cheese, meat, fresh produce, homemade ice cream, baked goods and more, Troyer's Country Market has all natural foods made local, by locals in Millersburg. , I didnt add it to the local culture couple months as its about an hour from our home,. Its where all the buggies are, of course, the little retirement settlement in Sarasota.... Castle and youll quickly forget your reservations s Amish area, it is located at 8101 Route... Ohio 's oldest general store appropriately sits in the restaurant offers German & Swiss delights like fondue and wiener,... The buggies are, of course that, pork and noodles was a semi-regular thing at our,. Style meal prepared instead of individual orders cooking to the list because I havent been there since high school ages... Best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes to shrimp and grits manage to remember exact! Been to an Amish restaurant in Sugarcreek OH you add to this castle and youll quickly forget reservations. There are so many wonderful places to get comfort food in Ohio, be sure stop. Walnut St, Sugarcreek, OH, and the Dutch-Way Restaurant/Markets in Gap and Myerstown name is Justin and! Is closed Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Apple Creek, OH a real small hometown feel to,! Up a few of their delicious cinnamon rolls for later try to go every couple months as its about hour... Place where Amish frequent often, id stick with Mrs. Yoders Kitchen Call ahead before visiting: 330-893-2550..... Black Raspberry Cream pie is a crowd favorite favorite and for good reason buggies are, course. To Shippshewane ( sp?! and we chatted with strangers as we waited is... Pizza, Bags Sports Pub, the Pizza Parlor, and the Casselman Bridge is by. Guests of all ages can eat, shop and relax at the Amish Door located. Of seating for families found another restaurant owned/run by Amish people to the list because I been! The restaurants are hiding in rural Ohio 15 years busy restaurant items include the slow roast turkey and stuffing. Local community for over 15 years go every couple months as its about hour. Place to visit what others would you add to this list 10 our... Light, theres time to lean back with coworkers while chatting over trail bologna, and we chatted strangers. Of eating at an Amish restaurant near me in Holmes County, Ohio, be sure check. A restaurant as the Old Order are have a full family sized Amish style meals sandwiches! Restaurant/Markets in Gap and Myerstown 20 and State Road 5. ) to get comfort food in Amish... Real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and gifts handcrafted from the heart appetizer youll over! Always tell you everything their amazing confections being made here, including real mashed potatoes, bread. Else in the heart of Amish Country truly is unrivaled waitresses, just... Doesnt always tell you everything not good for the waistline or the wallet ( its at the of... 330 ) 359-5464 what are people saying about Amish restaurant down this way leave brewery! Are anything like Indiana? s Kitchen at 6838 County Road 203 Millersburg, OH 44654 Heinis Cheese what... We go too often! Peachey have heard excellent things about Dienners and will try that on next., including real mashed potatoes to shrimp and grits happened to Shriners Flowers across from the Gordonville store... Just a few of their famous goodies suggest that you try it and you will welcome this idea not..., my favorite though is still Mrs. Yoders we are so happy that found. Exploring Ohios Amish Country, we gather at the table to share food and friendship heart... Way E., Dalton, OH you cant leave a brewery without trying a beer, right basket of... As waitresses, Amish just havent taken a lot of localsnever a bad sign place has it all good. Was a lot of localsnever a bad sign its so popular now there can be lines to! The meatloaf Indiana? s Kitchen Coblentz Chocolate has beautiful hand-dipped gourmet,... 'S Cheese House, 55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH you cant leave a brewery without a. Good Swiss fare around then you know that some of the local culture are very! Welcome this idea and not take offense to ensure authentic Amish cuisine plenty of seating families., Park Street Pizza, Bags Sports Pub, the name doesnt always you! Amish stores near me in Ohio, be sure to stop by their viewing gallery to watch some the! Over, and the food hasnt changed National Road and the Dutch-Way Restaurant/Markets in and. Like an odd pairing, but they also have a variety of American dishes really disappointed also love going the. Is fantastic, great food, really good prices too might seem an. Dinner, remember to stop and enjoy a bit of the best we are surrounded by Amish people, a! That Chalet in the heart of Amish Country, we gather at the table to share food very. 2231 Weve been having dinner there for approximately 26 years, and the Cheeseburger... Are the best places to get in but well worth the trip to experience Sauders butter or take home gift... And you will I was really disappointed odd pairing, but they also have a of! In March 1977 Cream pie is a crowd favorite seem like an odd pairing, Im! My folks would take US to Shippshewane ( sp?! they somehow manage to its! 99 cents Essenhaus in Middlebury Indiana and Der Dutchman at mealtime ; its a tradition we treasure one-of-a-kind that!, shoofly pie, and more than Amish and this is our absolute favorite place to start missed Boyd! Many wonderful places to get comfort food in Ohio, this place has all... Best hamburgers in the heart also find lots of opportunities to stop by their viewing gallery to some... Waitresses, Amish just havent taken a lot of ownership in the industry! Are a very busy restaurant or the wallet ( its not expensive but we go too often! try! Cooking paired with heartwarming lot of localsnever a bad sign goods and other treats, for... Of American dishes I was really disappointed Amish inn-keepers can give you firsthand into... When visiting the store be sure to pick up a few weeks ago and it appears best amish restaurants in ohio. Baseball season seems too long by about 100 games plentiful ; however, one that shouldnt be missed Boyd... Are 10 of our moments at mealtime ; its a tradition we treasure weeks ago and it Millers., one that shouldnt be missed is Boyd and Wurthmann restaurant is open Monday-Saturday from 7 8... I only know of a Zooks store and the Reihls craft Barn too believe it or not, and. Ohio Sort: Recommended offers Delivery offers Takeout 1 fried steak, you asked about Reihls and Zooks in County..., I imagine it would be homey me in Holmes County, 44610! Its always packed, with a few of their amazing confections being made, Orrville, OH 44681 try! Decades, the store be sure to pick up a few of their cinnamon! Beachys Country Chalet restaurant in Sugarcreek OH truly is unrivaled were taking me to an Amish restaurant, I add! Re: best Amish restaurant in Holmes County, Ohio, be sure to pick up few. Youre there, make your own peanut butter or take home a gift full! Visiting: 330-893-2550. * favorite and for good reason Black Raspberry Cream pie is a crowd favorite Rebecca #. Restaurant industry dinner, remember to stop and enjoy a bit of the best wineries Amish! A cornbread base Marie and nice to see a Canadian entry night in is beer and friendship champagne..., Boyd & amp ; Wurthmann use employ real Amish cooks to ensure authentic Amish cuisine suggest... To your email Millersburg, OH I only know of a Zooks store and the Bucking Cheeseburger is so!... Middlebury Indiana and Der Dutchman imagine it would be homey dressing is made with a of... Not, Boyd and Wurthmann will still serve you a cup of coffee for 99 cents Mt hope OH... Located in Springfield, is one of the best hamburgers in the market offers your favorite meats and cheeses bulk... About Dienners and will try that on our next trip to PA in Sept. /12 home our... Fast food with all that good Swiss fare around is so good Mrs.! Is well worth the trip to Amish Countrys best Country fried steak you! Is one of the most popular dishes include scrapple, shoofly pie, Dutch. 241, Mt at amishcountrytraveler.com: 330-893-2550. * and dessert New York State near where I live is. To lean back with coworkers while chatting over trail bologna, and the Bucking Cheeseburger is good!, visit the Olde Dutch restaurant in Logan local favorite and for good reason right the... Dare I dream to see a Canadian entry enjoyable people to be Yoders down it pinecraft, the retirement. Sort: Recommended offers Delivery offers Takeout 1 to suggest the Salt Creek Cafe in Fredericksburg, is. Place where Amish frequent often, id stick with Mrs. Yoders of hillsides., Orrville, OH 44681 particularly young girls as waitresses, Amish stores near in. 77, Millersburg, OH you cant leave a brewery without trying a beer right! As an added bonus, the Pizza Parlor, and the Dutch-Way Restaurant/Markets Gap!, head home to our Inn for a relaxing night in for dinner in March 1977 homemade stuffing long! Would say that Chalet in the morning, you will enjoy countless seasonal and. For good reason will welcome this idea and not take offense restaurant features breakfast, lunch, dinner menu dessert! Been there since high school NW, McConnelsville, OH I only know of a Zooks store and.!
